Daily Kos

The politics of mustard

Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 10:36:38 AM PDT

This is a politicized summary of a project I've been doing at the Pomona College Natural Farm, an urban one-acre farm in southern California and the subject of a previous essay on Docudharma.  The focus of this essay will be mustard, and mustard-growing.  There will be more such essays.

(reposted from Docudharma)

My interest in mustard (the plant, not merely the food) started with a garden I planted in the front yard of a friend of mine.  This was a strategically-placed front yard, near a major intersection of two boulevards, where everyone could see.  One of the things I noticed about this garden was that I could get incredible results out of mustard-growing; tiny seeds which produced huge plants.  (This, indeed, is why mustard is so noted in a New Testament parable (Matthew 13:31-32).)  I could also grow some wild-looking food plants in a really in-your-face location there.  How's that for the politics of mustard?

At some point, I started to think about producing mustard as an edible, tasty, nutritious weed.  This Spring at the Pomona College Natural Farm, on the east "adjunct" portion of the Farm, there is a preserved field of weeds, and the dominant weed in this field is... that’s right... mustard.  Not the type you put on your hot dog (Brassica nigra or Brassica juncea), nor the type that makes up "mustard greens" (Brassica juncea), nor a special oriental mustard which shares a species with turnips and bok choy (Brassica rapa), but, rather, wild mustard (sometimes labeled Brassica campestris, sometimes Sinapis arvensis).

Now, I remember reading in an article in the journal Plant Breeding ("Hybridizations among Brassica napus, B. Rapa, B. Juncea and their two weedy relatives B. nigra and Sinapis arvensis under open pollination conditions in the field," Plant Breeding 115, 470-473 (1996)), that suggested that wild mustard and domesticated mustard did not crossbreed.  So I haven’t tried to crosspollinate those mustards.  But I will be trying to do at least one crosspollination exercise this semester at the Farm.

I am so interested in mustard these days for several reasons.  First off, mustard seeds are rather small, thus rather cheap as an eventual source of food if you are buying by weight.  (I can especially recommend Peaceful Valley as a good deal on seed.)  This is an important consideration if you are gardening on a budget.  (NOTE TO GROWERS: there really isn't supposedly much time left in the growing season this year, as mustards are a cold-season vegetable.  But this depends upon where you live -- here in southern California it gets hot plenty.)  Second, mustard grows easily and produces a lot of food, which is high in vitamins A and C.  Third, mustard is a tough plant; it’s frost-resistant, which means that mustard is often the main surviving crop in unusually cold southern California winters.  Fourth, I’d like to see if some of the cultivars of mustard that I’m working with will spread as weeds.  If people are to "live off of the land," as should be the goal in an era threatened by abrupt climate change, then they should be able to eat weeds.

Here is a photograph of some wild mustard at the Farm, which my friend Brian tells me is growing all over the Chino Hills.  This is indeed edible mustard, but not very tasty and not very filling.

**********  

This winter, the main edible weed to spring up in Los Angeles County is malva, a type of mallow.  Malva is edible, mind you, but it’s bland; and so I think it’s reasonable that we begin to cultivate weeds which have some spicy kick to them; thus mustard.  

Malva grows everywhere; in February there were big fields of it growing everywhere in southern California.  Here is the space just north of the Pomona College Natural Farm, under the oak trees.

Apparently grounds maintenance spread some kind of herbicide over this malva at some later point, because here’s the same field later, mostly dead.  Malva is often regarded as an invasive, non-native species; yet removing this malva could have been done through weeding, or with a "weed-whacker." Or, hell, they could have just made a big salad out of the stuff, and eaten it.  If the Pomona College Farm really wishes to be an "organic" farm, they can’t be using chemical herbicides being used near the Farm itself.  (I have no idea which herbicide they used, whether chemical or natural.)

**********

Now, malva has medicinal uses; many of them are listed on the Plants for a Future webpage.  But my real interest here is mustard.  There's plenty of malva out there; weeded areas need to have a weed which is versatile, and I think of mustard as that weed.  Mustard, especially cultivated mustard, has numerous practical uses; if we are to spread the practical growing of plants to the people of this area (and especially to those who wish to live well on low monetary incomes) we will need to be spreading practical plants such as mustard.

There will be a social agenda to my experiments with mustard.  So many people play so little part in the global money economy because they have so little money.  If we are to create spaces outside of the money economy, spaces in which people can "live off of the land" even in cities, we must (among other things) spread varieties of plant and animal which can enable ordinary people to live cheaply, or to live off of the money economy altogether.  This will mean an aggressive guerrilla gardening program; and it will mean finding and using plants as vehicles for people to "get by."  I can see a series of articles in this vein: this one is about mustard, but the next one could be about garlic, or peas and beans, or maize, or another plant essential to living.

The word "mustard" comes from Latin: the Romans used to mix unfermented grape juice, or "must," with mustard seed until it acquired that "burning" flavor, thus the Latin name "mustum ardens" or "burning wine," which was later shortened to "mustard."

Now, so far I have been using the mustard I’ve grown at the Farm to cook and eat.  The Giant Southern Curled mustard is quite spicy, so I prefer to cook it.  The tendergreens, which have a spoon-shaped leaf, are also a mustard, and I’ve stashed a bowl, a fork, and a bottle of balsamic vinegar to eat them in impromptu salads.  My most successful tendergreens are pictured below.

I prefer tendergreen mustards to lettuce (and use it for all of the same purposes), but they flower quickly, unlike the Giant Southern Curleds, which have a spicy taste but which flower late.  One of my several successful fields of Giant Southern Curleds is pictured below.

I've been eating a lot of these Giant Southern Curleds, as they grow like crazy.  Raw they're kind of raspy.  You can cook them just a little bit for a full, rich flavor not too much unlike cooked spinach, but much better.  There is also a red mustard, some of which one can find at the Farm, and a Florida broadleaf mustard, which I suspect is the variety of the huge mustard growing just north of the wooden spool at the Farm.

 

The above photo is a volunteer -- at the time of this writing my own personal Florida broadleaf plantings are barely up.  Yeah, you can eat that whole damn thing.

The above photo is of a red mustard embedded in another Brassica plant, looking like a cabbage or collard green.  The red mustard is the one in the middle.  They’re quite spicy when eaten raw.

Mustard is, of course, the name of a condiment made by crushing mustard seeds.  I haven’t grown a crop of seeds yet; the tendergreens have flowered, but tendergreen mustard will not make a spicy mustard seed.  More promising for condiment mustard is the Giant Southern Curled, but at the Farm the current crop hasn’t flowered yet.

There is a flour that can be made from yellow mustard, credited by the Alternative Field Crops Manual as being an "excellent emulsifying agent and stabilizer and, consequently, it is used in sausage preparation."

There are numerous medicinal uses for mustard.  Drugs.com tells us that "Mustard itself is used as a food flavoring, forage, emetic, diuretic, and as a topical treatment for inflammatory conditions such as arthritis and rheumatism.  Mustard also has antioxidant activity and pharmacological effects on cardiovascular disease, cancer, and diabetes."

A website selling "mustard rub" tells us: "Mustard seed is an ancient remedy for increasing circulation and oxygen as well as for assisting your body in eliminating acid waste and toxins."

Mustard produces a mustard oil, which is commonly used as a vegetable oil.  Mustard oil is only 5% saturated fat, making it the lowest in saturated fat of the vegetable oils (Wikipedia).  However, "due to its high content of erucic acid, which is considered noxious, mustard oil is not considered fit for consumption in the United States."  There is, however, a "Mustard Project" being funded by the Department of Energy, for growing mustard "for the dual purposes of biodiesel and organic pesticide production."  As one website tells us, its "processes focused on alternating mustard crops with wheat.  Once nice effect of this is that the biomass from the mustard (after harvesting the seed) could be used as the cellulose feedback for producing alcohol for biodiesel production."

Mustard is also grown as a "green manure" crop.  With "green manure" the crop is plowed into the soil to increase soil fertility.  Researchers at the Fort Hall Indian Reservation in Idaho have determined that mustard green manure is an effective alternative to pesticide use in growing potatoes.  

There are different varieties of mustard which should attract our interest.  A variety of Brassica juncea (subspecies tatsai) is grown in Szechuan in China for its large stems, and pickled to make "Zha cai".  I have ordered Zha cai seeds from a Canadian business; if the seeds get to me in time to be planted for this season we will hopefully have Zha cai late this spring or early this summer.

There is a plant called "garlic mustard," not technically a mustard, but of the mustard family Brassicaciae (Alliaria petiolata).  Garlic mustard was imported from Europe and grows mostly on the East Coast here in the US, where it is commonly regarded as an invasive species.  It is also, however, edible and (ostensibly) tasty; there are garlic mustard recipes for stir-fry and pesto that can be gotten off of the Web.  This indeed represents a political dilemma; invasive species can crowd out native species, but invasive species can also have qualities we like; edible, tastes good.

The mustard project I’ve begun at the Pomona College Natural Farm is an ongoing thing; I would like to encourage the readers of this article to contribute what they can, and take what they need, from it as it continues forward and as I focus upon other plants.

Tags: mustard, malva, Gardens, farms, subsistence (all tags) :: Previous Tag Versions

Permalink | 35 comments

  •  Eat your lawn (5+ / 0-)

    But my front garden is all non-edible - curb appeal takes a higher precedent I guess.  I'll get brave in a few years and use the front yard for edibles.  Maybe I'll start with mustard.  I like the fragrance.

  •  mmmmm....mustard! (3+ / 0-)

    Homer_Simpson_Sideart_Homebrew

    "The truth shall set you free - but first it'll piss you off." Gloria Steinem

    Iraq Moratorium

    by One Pissed Off Liberal on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 10:44:16 AM PDT

  •  Thank you so much (4+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Fabian, empathy, lgmcp, Cassiodorus

    for all this great information!

    I could have been a soldier... I had got part of it learned; I knew more about retreating than the man that invented retreating. --Mark Twain

    by NogodsnomastersMary on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 10:46:53 AM PDT

  •  Cutleaf toothwort (2+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    empathy, lgmcp, Cassiodorus

    is a delightful native mustard.  It's also a host to the Virginia white butterfly.  This butterfly has become less and less common because garlic mustard, the evil invasive non native mustard, has crowded the native mustards out.  The butterflies can lay their eggs on garlic mustard, but their larvae don't do as well.

    I would have never ID'd as a mustard except for the four petals on the flowers.  Basic plant ID: three petals => lily family, four petals arranged in a cross pattern => mustard family aka crucifera  

    Proud member of the Cult of Issues and Substance!

    by Fabian on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 10:47:31 AM PDT

    •  Indeed this is helpful! (2+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      Fabian, empathy

      Thanks for the ID for brassicaciae, too!

      Unfortunately, I live on the West Coast, & am not familiar with the East Coast ecology of which you speak.  Could you diary it please?

      "The freeway's concrete way won't show/ you where to run or how to go" -- Jorma Kaukonen

      by Cassiodorus on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 10:57:53 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  I don't know much about it! (2+ / 0-)

        Recommended by:
        empathy, Cassiodorus

        It's just a spring ephemeral that popped up.  Likely it hitched a ride with my other natives I bought from a nursery that sells rescued plants.  It's a perennial, not an annual and only puts out a few flowers.  As is the case with most spring ephemerals, it lives in shady woods racing to put out leaves, flowers and set fruit before the tree canopy cuts off light to the forest floor.  Then the ephemerals go dormant - they are often dormant for 9-10 months of the year.  

        Proud member of the Cult of Issues and Substance!

        by Fabian on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 11:08:15 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  Not an agricultural plant -- (1+ / 0-)

          Recommended by:
          Fabian

          but still good for the gene pool...

          "The freeway's concrete way won't show/ you where to run or how to go" -- Jorma Kaukonen

          by Cassiodorus on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 11:13:56 AM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  The toughest plants to propagate and grow (1+ / 0-)

            Recommended by:
            Cassiodorus

            are herbaceous plants that live in the woods.  Because they only grow for a portion of what we think of as the growing season, they grow very slowly and build up resources slowly.  Easy to destroy, hard to create.

            Also, since spring ephemerals are one of the first green things in the spring, deer eat them.  I planted my trillium in the closest thing I had to a deer proof place.  Alas, the drainage was too poor and the trillium failed.  Most of my other wildflowers have done well enough there - so I don't think I did too badly.

            When you get rescued plants which are just dug with a goodly chunk of native soil in order to avoid damage to the roots, you often get more than meets the eye.  It's fun IDing the freebies and hitchhikers.

            Proud member of the Cult of Issues and Substance!

            by Fabian on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 11:38:11 AM PDT

            [ Parent ]

            •  If the deer eat them -- (0+ / 0-)

              Don't the deer poop out their seeds too?  Symbiosis, no?

              "The freeway's concrete way won't show/ you where to run or how to go" -- Jorma Kaukonen

              by Cassiodorus on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 11:41:41 AM PDT

              [ Parent ]

              •  Before they bloom.... (1+ / 0-)

                Recommended by:
                Cassiodorus

                Deer love lilies and will eat the trillium before they set seed.  The two-three stems you may see is the sum total of the leaves that one plant will put out that season.  A few seasons of deer chomping and they just don't come back.

                Proud member of the Cult of Issues and Substance!

                by Fabian on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 11:57:07 AM PDT

                [ Parent ]

  •  Good stuff, thanks (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    empathy, Cassiodorus

    Reminds me of another edible weed, stinging nettles,  that supported the British poor during times of economic depression and wage struggle.  Hope it doesn't come to this any time soon!

    THE FOUR LOOM WEAVER

    I'm a four loom weaver, as many a man knows,
    I've nowt to eat and I've worn out m' clothes
    M' clogs are all broken, and stockings I've none.
    Thee'd hardly gi's tuppence for all I've gotten on.

    Old Billy O' Bent, he were telling us long
    We mayn't had better times if I'd nobbut held m' tongue.
    Well, I held m' tongue til I near lost m' breath,
    And I feel in m' hear that I'II soon clem to death

    I'm a four loom weaver, as many a man knows.
    I've nowt to eat and I've worn out m' clothes.
    Old Billy were right, but he ne'er were clemmed,
    He ne'er picked o'er in his liie.

    We held out for six weeks, thought each day were the last.
    We tarried and shifted til we were quite fast.
    We lived upon nettles while nettles were good.
    And Waterloo Porridge were best o' all food.

    Our Margaret declares, if hoo'd clothes to put on,
    Hoo'd go up t' London and see the great man
    And if things didn' alter when there hoo'd been
    Hoo' swears hoo'd fight til there blood up to th' e'en.

    I'm a four loom weaver as many a man knows.
    I've nowt to eat and I've worn out m' clothes
    Stockings I've none, nor looms to weave on,
    I've woven m'sen to far end.

    Notes:
    clem - starve;
    hoo'd - she'd

    Recorded by Killen, Gallant Lads are We; also MacColl

    "The extinction of the human race will come from its inability to EMOTIONALLY comprehend the exponential function." -- Edward Teller

    by lgmcp on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 10:53:36 AM PDT

  •  Thanks for the insight (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Cassiodorus

    I did not know most of this.  I do love mustard greens and many different types of table mustard, but I was unaware of so many different edible types.

    Another day, another devalued Dollar. -6.00, -6.21

    by funluvn1 on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 10:58:04 AM PDT

  •  Mustard can be a curse (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Cassiodorus

    to us tomato growers.  In central New Mexico, leaf hoppers like to dine on wild mustard.  By the time the mustard starts dying out, the weather is warm enought to start planting tomatoes.  Sometimes, the leaf hoppers get to the tomatoes and infect them with curly top virus.  I lost two plantings one year to the virus.

    My personal frustration for mustard notwithstanding, I think this is a great diary.  Thanks for sharing the work you're doing.

    This is not a time for a candidate who will offend no one; it is time for a candidate who takes clear stands and kicks ass - Molly Ivins

    by TigerMom on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 11:54:59 AM PDT

    •  thanks for the anecdote! (1+ / 0-)

      Recommended by:
      TigerMom

      I will research it further.

      "The freeway's concrete way won't show/ you where to run or how to go" -- Jorma Kaukonen

      by Cassiodorus on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 12:00:18 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  The leaf hoppers (1+ / 0-)

        Recommended by:
        Cassiodorus

        also took out the peppers that same year.  Many farmers in the Middle Rio Grande Valley lost a lot of inventory, not to mention income, because of the mustard/leaf hopper problem.

        Tomatoes and pepers - what can I tell ya?  It's the southwest.  The leaf hoppers like their salsa!

        This is not a time for a candidate who will offend no one; it is time for a candidate who takes clear stands and kicks ass - Molly Ivins

        by TigerMom on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 12:17:12 PM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  Isn't there a type of mustard -- (1+ / 0-)

          Recommended by:
          TigerMom

          that repels leaf hoppers?

          Maybe a mustard so spicy that the leaf hoppers die of indigestion?

          Jus' askin'...

          "The freeway's concrete way won't show/ you where to run or how to go" -- Jorma Kaukonen

          by Cassiodorus on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 12:18:44 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  Well, I don't know about that. (1+ / 0-)

            Recommended by:
            Cassiodorus

            What I do know is that the leaf hoppers don't acutally LIKE tomato and pepper plants.  Rather, they are searching for another food source once the mustard dies out.  I don't know if they are attracted to the tomatoes and peppers because of smell, shape or just proximity to mustard, but once they bite into the plant, the leaf hoppers go "Yuck!  No like!"  But by that point, the plant is infected.

            Here is brief synopsis of of curly top virus and leaf hoppers (it's a .pdf):

            http://www.cahe.nmsu.edu/...

            These little guys can be devastating to small farmers, particularly small organic farmers and gardeners (like myself).

            Best wishes for your on-going work!

            This is not a time for a candidate who will offend no one; it is time for a candidate who takes clear stands and kicks ass - Molly Ivins

            by TigerMom on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 12:32:43 PM PDT

            [ Parent ]

  •  I love mustard. (1+ / 0-)

    Recommended by:
    Cassiodorus

    As a child I often went out with my mother or grandmother and harvested wild mustard for cooked greens.  I've been a gardener for most of my 50 years on earth, and mustard is a standard in my garden.  I prefer hardy greens, and spinach doesn't hold a lot of thrill for me, but you mix some mustard, chard, kale, lambs quarter and collards in a pot and you've got something delectable.

    Here's to mustard, queen of gardens tame and wild.  Long may she wave.....

    Calling bullshit on "bracing rhetorical thrusters" since Fall 2006....put your words into action at Road2DC

    by Got a Grip on Mon Mar 03, 2008 at 02:04:10 PM PDT

Permalink | 35 comments